October 1, 2026
How does a town add more new housing in a single year than it built in almost any full decade before it, and still end up with the least affordable starter homes on the whole Kenai Peninsula? That is the question sitting underneath Homer's 2026 housing numbers, and it is the one worth answering before you compare Homer's median price to Soldotna's or Kenai's and assume you are looking at the same kind of gap everywhere.
Homer added 47 single-family homes and 37 multifamily units in 2024. That is more than double the city's average of 36 new housing units a year between 2013 and 2023, according to figures compiled from Alaska Multiple Listing Service data by the Kenai Peninsula Economic Development District (KPEDD). By any normal read of supply and demand, that kind of construction surge should have started closing the price gap between Homer and its neighbors. It didn't.
KPEDD's newly released 2026 Kenai Peninsula housing assessment defines a starter home as a single-family house between 800 and 1,400 square feet, the size range most first-time buyers and downsizers actually shop in. Here is what that specific slice of the market looked like across the peninsula last year.
| Market | 2025 median sale price |
|---|---|
| Homer, all single-family homes | $450,000 |
| Soldotna, all single-family homes | $373,000 |
| Kenai, all single-family homes | $355,000 |
| Homer starter homes (800–1,400 sq ft) | $386,500 |
| Kenai Peninsula, all starter homes | $289,000 |
| Alaska statewide, all starter homes | $320,000 |
A Homer starter home sold for roughly a third more than the peninsula-wide starter-home median last year. That is not a story about Homer being expensive in general terms. Soldotna and Kenai sit close enough to each other that the difference reads as normal local variation. Homer's premium is a different shape of number, and city planners have said publicly that it can't be explained away by population growth alone or by a simple lack of building activity, because the building activity is right there in the permit data.
The KPEDD assessment points to something more specific than land scarcity: Homer's existing housing stock is heavily weighted toward single-family homes, and the city's zoning code still treats duplexes and other missing-middle housing types as the exception rather than a default option in most residential districts. Land prices, financing costs and Homer's hillside topography all add friction to any project, but the zoning constraint is the one that doesn't ease up even when a builder has capital, a buyer and a buildable lot lined up.
That is the mechanism behind the paradox. A construction surge concentrated in the same housing types the market already has plenty of doesn't touch the starter-home gap, because the gap isn't really about total unit count. It's about which unit types are easy to permit. Add another single-family home in a district zoned almost exclusively for single-family homes and you've added supply, but you haven't added the smaller, cheaper-to-build unit types that would pull the starter-home median down.
Homer is in the middle of doing something about this. The city is rewriting Title 21, the section of Homer's municipal code governing zoning and land use, and the Planning Commission is scheduled to continue reviewing the new code into early 2027. Housing is one of the issues explicitly tied to implementing Homer's comprehensive plan through that rewrite. Short-term rentals are getting a separate look within the same process, as officials weigh whether the seasonal visitor economy is pulling homes out of the year-round supply. Both threads point at the same underlying question: does Homer's code currently let the market build what would actually bring costs down, or does it default to the housing type that's already expensive?
If you're comparing Homer to Soldotna or Kenai on price alone, this is the piece that doesn't show up in a median-price snapshot. The other two cities aren't necessarily easier to build duplexes or accessory units in either, but Homer's premium over the peninsula-wide starter-home number suggests its particular mix of topography and zoning is doing more to keep prices up than raw demand is.
The starter-home gap isn't isolated to buyers. A separate state Department of Labor and Workforce Development survey found the adjusted median rent for a two-bedroom apartment across the Kenai Peninsula Borough reached $1,336 a month in March 2026, up from $1,203 a year earlier, an 11.1 percent increase that was the second largest among the 11 Alaska areas the state tracks, behind only the Matanuska-Susitna Borough. Vacancy among those surveyed units fell to 3.8 percent, with just 18 of 473 units open. Those figures cover communities across the peninsula rather than Homer specifically, so they can't tell you exactly how much Homer rents moved on their own, but they describe the same tight rental market that pushes people toward buying sooner than they might otherwise plan.
Homer's own numbers, folded into the city's comprehensive plan process, show that about half of the city's renter households, 358 of 702 surveyed, spend more than 30 percent of their income on housing and are considered cost-burdened under the standard federal threshold. In resident surveys conducted during that planning process, 68 percent of respondents said housing was too expensive and 66 percent said the community needed more housing options for people entering the market or looking to downsize. Those numbers came directly from residents describing their own experience, not from an outside assumption about what Homer needs.
It would be easy to assume Homer just needs more vacant land released for development. A 2023 housing review identified 1,163 vacant tax parcels inside city limits, averaging 1.3 acres each. On paper that sounds like plenty of room. In practice, KPEDD's 2026 assessment found many of those parcels face real development barriers:
Those constraints don't make the land unusable. They make it more expensive to use, which pushes the eventual sale price up regardless of what zoning district the parcel sits in. Combine that with a code that still limits duplexes and accessory dwelling units in most residential zones, and you get a market where both the land and the rules make the cheaper housing types harder to build than the ones Homer already has enough of.
None of this means Homer is a bad place to buy or that the price gap is permanent. It means the gap is structural rather than incidental, which changes what you should actually be asking. If you're comparing a Homer listing to something similar in Soldotna or Kenai, the median price difference reflects more than lot size or finish quality. It reflects what each city's zoning code currently allows on that lot and what it costs to prepare that specific parcel for a foundation.
If you're buying now, ask what zoning district a property sits in and whether that district currently allows a duplex or an accessory dwelling unit, because Title 21's outcome could change what's buildable on comparable lots within the next year or so. If you're weighing land specifically, ask about wetlands delineation, slope, and utility proximity before you factor in the cost of any future zoning flexibility. And if you're comparing Homer's overall affordability to a town you're leaving, remember that the peninsula-wide starter-home median of $289,000 describes towns with a different housing mix than Homer's, not a lower bar you should expect Homer to hit on its own.
Does the Title 21 rewrite affect a property I'm already looking at? The rewrite is still in Planning Commission review as of this fall, with work continuing into early 2027, so no zoning district has changed yet. A property's current zoning is what applies today. Ask the city's planning department about a specific parcel before assuming future flexibility.
Is Homer's price gap likely to close soon? Nothing in the current data points to a fast correction. The construction surge that started in 2024 hasn't moved the starter-home median down, because it hasn't been paired with a zoning change yet. That could shift once Title 21 is finalized, but the timeline runs into 2027.
Why does Homer cost more than Soldotna or Kenai for a similar-sized home? Part of it is topography and land prep costs tied to wetlands, slope and utility access. Part of it is a housing stock still weighted toward single-family homes in a code that limits duplexes and accessory units in most residential districts, which keeps the cheaper-to-build housing types scarce even when overall construction picks up.
If you're weighing a Homer purchase against another peninsula town and want to know what a specific lot's zoning actually allows right now, or where the Title 21 process stands on the parcel you're considering, Valerie Buss and the Kachemak Real Estate Group team can walk through it with you. Schedule a free consultation before you write an offer based on last year's numbers.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Leading with our core standards and values we approach every decision with honesty and integrity. We take great responsibility in doing the right thing because it is the right thing to do.